Middle East and Africa | A damning opinion

The world court says Israel’s occupation is illegal

But will the International Court of Justice’s ruling have any effect?

Judges leave after delivering a non-binding ruling on the legal consequences of the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem at the International Court of Justice in The Hague, The Netherlands on July 19th 2024
Photograph: Getty Images
|Jerusalem

FOR FIFTY-SEVEN years Israel has justified its control over the territories it captured in 1967 with a combination of historic, legal, diplomatic and security arguments: The eastern part of Jerusalem and the west bank of the Jordan river were inhabited by Jews from biblical times; Israel had not captured the territory from a sovereign country but from an illegal occupation by the Jordanian kingdom, which attacked Israel first in 1967; as a small country surrounded by enemies, it needed to hold the territory to protect itself and besides, the final status of the area would be decided through negotiations.

More from Middle East and Africa

Africa’s surprising new age of rail

Sino-American tensions are playing out on the tracks

The far-right has captured Israel’s police

Binyamin Netanyahu’s coalition partner is eroding the force’s independence


To see the future of urban warfare, look at Gaza

Western armies are studying the horrifying conflict for tactical lessons


More from Middle East and Africa

Africa’s surprising new age of rail

Sino-American tensions are playing out on the tracks

The far-right has captured Israel’s police

Binyamin Netanyahu’s coalition partner is eroding the force’s independence


To see the future of urban warfare, look at Gaza

Western armies are studying the horrifying conflict for tactical lessons


Israel bombs the Hamas military mastermind behind the October 7th attack

If he is dead it could hasten the end of the Gaza war

Iran’s new hope: a cardiologist president

He is said to detest the capital, Tehran. Can he master its politics?

Why food is piling up on the edge of Gaza

Thousands of tonnes of food and medicine are still waiting to get in